Hall Of Fame

Bondage DesiresSpread Wide and Tied TightTop PainBondage DesiresFrejas forced experience - Part 1Bound in a classic fuck me position on the leather Sexuallybroken couch with her legs spread open wide, Simone is completely vulnerable, totally exposed. She is going nowhere. Her pink pussy is like a bullseye for the dicking down she is about to receive.Fucking Dungeon Fucking DungeonSenses deprived and awaiting masters approachChloroformed and tied girlFucking DungeonBondage DesiresTop PainSocietySM Bound BlondeAshley Renee Bondage & FetishBondage DesiresPerfect SlaveRebecca Bondage Slave serves her MasterShadow SlavesDarling returns for her live show with a cat 5 hogtie suspension, predicament bondage, a challenging forward bend suspension, and AMAZING orgasms Blonde & Busty BondageBondage DesiresBondage DesiresShadow SlavesWith her ample ass, Phoenix Marie's begs to be broken in. I follow my instinct to stretch out and violate her buttHot Asian in Lesbian BDSM actionPerfect Slave Katarina tied naked in the bathroomFucking DungeonInxesse.com - 20,000  Images - Video Downloads - Great ContentHere's something you don't get to see every day, an innocent looking hottie that's not into just plain old fucking, this piece of eye candy is into light bondage and submissionTight restraints, Hot orgasmsTop PainBondage Forted Jada Stevens anally dominated and penetrated with food and cockWatch brunette and blonde lezdom videos with fucking machinesDon't get us wrong, we love breaking down sexual superstars, but there is something about a fresh face that is just so much fun to fuck. Katrina Jade is new to the industry and she's decided that she wants to do her first Bondage and Rough Sex shoot witThe best part about brats like Penny Barber is that you never need to look for reasons to beat their fucking asses. They are always trying to push your buttons, just to pretend like they have some kind of power over you. Penny's mistake is that she thinkFormer fashion &runway model is bound, trapped on a Sybain. Brutal orgasms are ripped from her helpless pleading body, she begs for mercy & gets noneBondage DesiresBondage Forted Bondage DesiresIt is hard to appreciate how difficult it can be to stay in bondage sometimes. Some ties are just far more strenuous than they look at firstBondage DesiresAnikka Albright looks like a barbie doll. Perfect blonde hair, tan and lean, she is the ultimate fuck toy. This was a girl built for dick. We like taking barbie dolls and using them for exactly what they are designed for. This perfectly put together suckSarah Shevon gets double penetrated in intense interracial gang bangSkin Diamond is facing a full on sexual Armageddon. Once we've got her tied down and helpless we take a good look at her amazing body we decide not to hold back. She is on her back with her head thrown back and her legs pulled up. It lets us bury cock inHouse slaves Jessie Cox and Kait Snow are taught a lesson about leaving messes on the carpet - the hard way
Rough 18

Today's Galleries

Amateur TiedBeautiful redhead Claire Robbins has a lot going for her, but it's nothing compared to what's about to happen to her. She's bound down in what we call the classic fuck me position. Well, with an invitation like that we're not going to take it easyEmma Haize said the magic words as soon as we got her on set. I just love the feeling of someone having complete control over me. Well, she is going to have more than enough of that, today. Matt Williams is a veteran when it comes to dealing with girlPenny Barber is known in the bondage porn world for being a bit of a brat. Back talk and sass are all she knows. She is the kind of girl that knows she can take more punishment than most people are prepared to give out. That is why we keep so many peopleAmateur TiedStrict RestraintBondage Desires Perfect SlaveLong leged blonde tied by transparent foilBondage DesiresSamantha Joons tied cut open pantyhose dildo in pussyPublic DisgraceMy bound whoresKristina is brought into the world of true Master and slave relationships with bondage, torture and intense orgasms Sexy Amorina is subjected to more punishment from her master, this time he has her on the bed in just a pair of stockings and pantiesBondage DesiresVeruca James is a classic beauty that looks way too refined to do the filthy things she does. But this is no lady. Veruca is a complete sexual freak. She is one of the best deep throaters in the industry today, and can take a face fucking like no other. TFelony returns for intense flexibility bondage, squirts all over her face and tits, rides the sybian & cums so much she practically forgets her name.Bondage DesiresBlack-haired girl tied to a poleGaia really really loves to deep throat. It is what she was put on this planet to do. She worships it as if the cock was the very air she breathes. This compact little Asian simply can't get enough of the dick and here at Sexuallybroken we truly apprecia Tied Petula dildoed on the rocking-chairSocietySMDarling brings something to the table that so many people overlook. She is a hard-core sexual Olympian and she loves showing it off. A little tight bondage is all it takes to get her wet and once she is hot and ready all she wants is the roughest fuck imaTop PainMy Bound WifeWe shot a few scenes with Kristine Kahill and have seen an amazing transformation from her. She may look like an innocent girl-next-door, but inside is a sexual wild-child, begging to be tied down and sexually broken. Her favorite time to cum is when a coBeauties In Bondage Slave trainee learns to be a better fuck puppetSocietySMGirl in the leather on the shellboardSlaves in LoveSexy SettingsPictures of tied up girlfriends in this galleryBlonde ass fucked until she squirts, her perfect body totally rocked by machines on high, she does DP and deep, mad hot anal fucking Perfect SlaveBondage FortedElin tied up the first timeHoly shit. We found ourselves a certified bondage newbie and we're going to take full advantage of her. Mandy Muse likes to be submissive, she likes to feel taken advantage of, but when we asked her what kind of experience she had with BDSM we were not eStormy Evans vs. The Pallet WallEverybody loves Mia Li. She is bubbly, eager and loves to fuck. Too bad for this hot Asian piece of ass we are not fucking her today. Today is not about her pleasure, it is going to be about binding her down and turning her face hole into a pussy for ourTied and vibed blond girl Members vote to have the Governess punished along with the house slaves. The Governess is whipped and used, while the Steward makes good use of the hoTop PainBondage DesiresSamantha Bentley tied up naked in our bedroomAva Devine is a sexual force to be reckoned with, but then again, so is the huge cock that is about to be buried in her ass. Oiled up and tied down, there is no escape for this big-tittied beauty. She is going to take a pounding at both ends, struggling tHot amateur wives ballgagged, taped and readyDecorative Girls

Disgraced 18-$1.00

MILF Humiliation-$1.00

SocietySM-$29.95

Bondage orgasms-$24.95

Perfect Slave-$24.95

Fucking Dungeon-$34.95

Smothered Slave-$24.95

Bizarre Adult Club-$29.95

InFemDom-$29.95

FemDomTime-$29.95

BondageHere-$29.95

Chantas Bitches-$24.95

Fucked and Bound-$24.95

Device Bondage-$55.00

Hogtied-$34.95

Wired Pussy-$29.75

Whipped Ass-$29.85

Water Bondage-$21.00

Ultimate Surrender-$21.95

Public Disgrace-$29.95

Everything Butt-$19.99

Bondage By Request

Amateur Tied

Charlotte Fetish

InXesse-$24.95

Fetish Nation-$24.95

Ashley Renee-$16.95

Decorative Girls

Shadow Slaves

Sandra Bound-$14.95

Yesterday's Galleries

We love return visitors like Asian beauty Gaia. When a girl comes running back to us we know they've had the most intense bondage and rough sex experience of their life and that they are looking to take it up another level. We don't mess around, but weDarling returns for a hard dose of intense back breaking hogtie, bow suspension, straight legged pile driver, & gets an extremely intense sybian ride.Claire Robbins is our favorite little redheaded girl next door. She has this sweet and innocent face but that banging body of hers tells us that she has the goods. If you've ever heard the phrase over a barrel before, you'll know what it means after18yr old w/huge natural tits, a perfect booming ass, suffers while spread out & helpless This is her first bondage experience, so excited she squirtsBondage DesiresAshley Lane has changed her tune. She says, through the rag in her mouth that the vibrators hurt her clit. She screams like the dildo cramming her full isn't exactly the kind of satisfaction she begged us for. Maybe it's the shame of having so many peopHot mature slut wants to be tied up and cum hosed on her face Ashley Renee Bondage and FetishMaddy O'Reilly came to me for tight bondage. She showed up on my door step asking, practically begging, to have rope wound around her until she could hardly move, to have me spank her, then caress her, or whatever else it would take to make her feel alivDrunk girl tied to the tableMonica arrousing and licking tied KateErina tethered to the tree in ragged dressA girl like Tegan Tate deserves a very warm welcome. At just 4'11 and 100 lbs, it is pretty brave for this tiny tart to come to the hottest Bondage and Rough Sex site on the web. She gets exactly what the others do, though, no special treatment for herEnjoy female asian domination with sexy and busted mature sluts A very sexy blonde gets her hands bound and her mouth gaggedSocietySMBondage ForteExtreme Tits TortureBondage DesiresKinky amateurs bedroom gamesSara tight ellbow tied If Mei Mara had any common sense she would have stayed in her fucking hole. I guess the grass is always greener on the other side.Nurse and Dominatric cum swap massive loadPaula hogtied the very first timeDomina and her tied busty blond subgirlWe are happy to have back the fresh face Latina next door known as Selma Sins, along with her powers of super drool. We have never met someone who can produce the amounts of thick drool that this one can, we should put up hazard safety cones. We'll try tMaddy O'Reilly seems, at first glance, to be far too innocent to be fucking around with the likes of us. But give her 2 seconds in bondage and she reveals herself to be exactly the kind of intense slut that comes crawling to us looking for the best bondaBondage Desires Live feeds are something our crew lives for. There is something thrilling about streaming our handy work live. The energy is completely different. Part of it is the fun of putting on a show, the other part is the element of the unknown. We never know whatCharlotte FetishTied gilr hung on piercingThe busty and always eager Bella Rossi takes on the hardest live sexual show out on the net today. This is not the sort of shoot for the pillow princesses. Lucky for us, Bella is just the sort of person that lives for a through dicking down as only we canPretty and petite are two words that perfectly describe Emma Haize. She can't expect to go around looking so hot without getting stuffed so full of cock she is nearly split in two. When a tiny little tart like her comes along it is almost a challenge toSabre BondageJustine Joli returns to Whipped Ass as Whipped Ass Girl Of The Month. Here is a taste of what's to come Strict RestraintIsis Love bound with a tight pussy rope and gaggedChanel Preston is a high speed sex machine that is built to fuck and fueled by cock. Well, we have a pair of dicks to make sure we fill her up right. Bound between a pair of posts, she has no place to go while we work her over. She'll get fucked until shExtreme Tits TortureDixon Mason sums up the allure of device bondage perfectly. With rope there is wiggle room, there is a chance to writhe and escape, but with iron there is no hope. It is cold and unyielding, the perfect counter point to the sensuality of rope. She loves bSweet blond girl in a brutal hogtiedCheck out the most extreme BDSM lezdome videos with busted chicks Training a slut is simple. First your break their will, then you replace it. Maggie Mead is half way there. Breaking her is easy and fun.Master Liam torments Audrey LeighTwo Blondes and a Brunette walked into our studios. The joke is that they thought they would be able to leave without getting plowed first.To Siouxsie Q, bondage is a way of life. It's part of her identity. She considers it a guiding philosophy, almost a religion. Well, if that's the case then we are the high priests and it is time for a service. Siouxsie is a beautiful sacrifice to the goSlaves in LoveRemy LaCroix reeks of innocence. However when the ropes go on, she transforms into a submissive whore! Face fucking, pussy torture and brutal orgasmsBondage Desires
Public Disgrace

Best Galleries

Maggie Mead has a lot of hardware in that cunt of hers. It makes it extra sensitive and the place she loves to have touched the most.Hot Mom gets tied and fucked sillyErina is hard hogtied on a bedPerfect SlaveWatch the most extreme lezdom movies with sexy and het up chicksSlaves in LoveBondage Desires Cherry Waxed and WhippedElins forced laundryroom fantasyWhat we have done to Elise Graves so far is so hot that Maggie Mead needs a minute to herself. We sure as hell don't mind watching her.Crystal vs. Dixie's CropHazel gets it. She understands. She knows that bondage is freedom, pain is pleasure, and suffering is sweet. I chose her for this because I love seeing her suffer. She is so natural and open when she has been bound. There is no pretense about her. I chosePublic DisgraceBondage Desires Fucking DungeonMarilyn Scott Hot MILF tied up and fucked upTop PainFucking DungeonKatarina tied up in bed - Part 2Tina tied naked fully spread - gets fuckedEnza tied fully spread struggles against the ropes - dildo on her hairy wet pussy Aroused blonde tied and stretched on a matAmateur TiedRain DeGrey enjoys watching Ashley Lane cum. It's nice to see someone else get their pussy tortured with intense vibrations for a bit. This beautiful redhead has a banging body, firm tits, and an amazingly sensitive pussy. So sensitive that a few minutesBondage DesiresDahlia Sky is beautiful and blonde, with a body built for sin. She is just the type of toy that a man can not wait to play with. And today we are going to ragdoll fuck this toy until she can no longer lift her head up off the bed. That calm and quiet lookSavannah vs. The Pussy TeaseAmateur gymnast get punished Ashley Renee Bondage and FetishSlaves in LoveLiteral streams of cum shoot out of the super famous porn star's pussy. See the legend soak everything in sight with EPIC orgasms filmed by 3 camerasEmma tied up the very first timeAshley Renee Bondage and FetishCombine one deep throat, a sexy, flexible body and a desire to please and you have the make-up of our perfect bondage model, Chanel Preston.Dahlia Sky comes across as the shy and quiet type, but she wouldn't be here if she didn't have a sexual beast lurking inside of her. We know how to unleash the deepest desires of every girl that comes through our doors. A hot blonde with a smoking body, Bondage DesiresNikki Darling is one of our favorite girls to have around. She has a banging body that just doesn't quit. She is thin, flexible, and can take whatever we decide to dish out. She has the right attitude for bondage, too. When some girls would be begging foBig titted bitch bound on a sybian and made to cum over and over, metal breast bondageTied VirginsThe two slaves pleasure each otherRain DeGrey is a veteran of our sadistic torments, and yet she keeps coming back for more. Her terrified face as Elise's mean electric zapper comes closer is a sight you do not want to miss, nor are newbie decoration model Ashley Lane's wide eyes as sheKatrina Jade is back and brings her all natural DD tits to the table. This Daddy's girl is a relative newcumer to the industry, but if her smoking looks and huge tits are any indication, she will go far. The shy act is great, we always love that. It's s Liv vs. The Mummy MoundsBondage FortedPerfect SlaveSeashore lezdom play and strapon fuck picsHazel Hypnotic is no stranger to our strange ways. She has been with us for a while and knows exactly what we're capable of. Or at least she thinks she knows. We are going to blind fold her and let her imagination run wild while we prepare to do the unimMarie captured in the attic - Part 2This garbage blonde whore mother of two from Beverly Hills gets what she deserves

Top Free Sites




BDSM Galleries

  1. 26/07/2014 Cute babe tape-gagged, roped and undressed (18 thumbs)
  2. 26/07/2014 Hot milf enjoying her first time bondage (15 thumbs)
  3. 26/07/2014 Madison gets roped and punished by master (16 thumbs)
  4. 26/07/2014 Busty cutie tied up, ball-gagged, dildoed and fucked (17 thumbs)
  5. 26/07/2014 Two horny schoolgirls tied together and fucked (14 thumbs)
  6. 25/07/2014 Cute brunette roped, stripped, pegged and used (15 thumbs)
  7. 25/07/2014 Trained, roped, hooked and fucked with strapon (15 thumbs)
  8. 24/07/2014 Brunette gets bound, stripped, paddled and trained (18 thumbs)
  9. 24/07/2014 Eva fixed with stocks, pegged and whipped (17 thumbs)
  10. 23/07/2014 Blonde hogtied and harness gagged outdoors (17 thumbs)
  11. 22/07/2014 Bella caged, roped, hogtied and double teamed (14 thumbs)
  12. 21/07/2014 Cute girls tied at home for the first time (14 thumbs)
  13. 20/07/2014 Erina tethered to the tree in ragged dress (15 thumbs)
  14. 19/07/2014 Pretty slave cuffed, ball-gagged and pleased (15 thumbs)
  15. 18/07/2014 Busty blonde roped, clamped and strapon fucked (18 thumbs)
  16. 17/07/2014 Aroused blonde tied and stretched on a mat (17 thumbs)
  17. 16/07/2014 Tied to the pole in an impossible split position (17 thumbs)
  18. 15/07/2014 Fatima gets her pale body bounded by rough rope (18 thumbs)
  19. 14/07/2014 Girlfriend gets tied, tape-gagged and fucked (18 thumbs)
  20. 13/07/2014 Dutch amateur female slave in bound breast torment (14 thumbs)
  21. 12/07/2014 Brunette cutie tit tortured, roped and fucked (15 thumbs)
  22. 11/07/2014 London girl tied in doggy position and strapon fucked (17 thumbs)
  23. 10/07/2014 Big tit brunette tightly tied, ball-gagged and vibed (14 thumbs)
  24. 09/07/2014 Chained slave trained for double insertion (18 thumbs)
  25. 08/07/2014 Amber tightly roped, pegged and vibed to orgasm (17 thumbs)
  26. 07/07/2014 Brunette tied on a chair, pegged & waxed (17 thumbs)
  27. 06/07/2014 Naked girl in sexy green bondage and collar (17 thumbs)
  28. 05/07/2014 Trapped in the examination room and tortured (16 thumbs)
  29. 04/07/2014 Morgan handcuffed, ball-gagged and vibed (15 thumbs)
  30. 03/07/2014 Lavender is punished and fucked in bondage (16 thumbs)
  31. 02/07/2014 Natali fixed with stocks & forced to cum (14 thumbs)
  32. 01/07/2014 Beautiful madison gets toe-tied and gagged (16 thumbs)
  33. 30/06/2014 Darling roped, ball-gagged, pegged and forced to cum (17 thumbs)
  34. 29/06/2014 Trapped in the examination room and tortured (14 thumbs)
  35. 28/06/2014 Charlie handcuffed and fucked with machine (16 thumbs)
  36. 27/06/2014 Natasha gets her tits tied stretched and clamped (18 thumbs)
  37. 26/06/2014 Talia tied to a medical chair and tortured (14 thumbs)
  38. 25/06/2014 First time tied, suspended, vibed and got the enema (18 thumbs)
  39. 24/06/2014 Girl in boots cuffed, ball-gagged and waxed (17 thumbs)
  40. 23/06/2014 Sexy bondage cat-lady dildoing in a barn (18 thumbs)
  41. 22/06/2014 London girl tied in doggy position and strapon fucked (15 thumbs)
  42. 21/06/2014 Blonde cuffed, ball-gagged, tortured and dildoed (15 thumbs)
  43. 20/06/2014 Redhead tied to the stool and fucked with strapon (16 thumbs)
  44. 19/06/2014 Autumn gagged, blindfolded, and tied up in knots (17 thumbs)
  45. 18/06/2014 Wenona gets roped, spanked, dildoed and vibed (18 thumbs)
  46. 17/06/2014 Petite girl gets to enjoy some rough rope (18 thumbs)
  47. 16/06/2014 Calico gets trained and examined in clinic (17 thumbs)
  48. 15/06/2014 Two girls on one with dildos and bondage (16 thumbs)
  49. 14/06/2014 Celestia tied spread eagle and machine fucked (18 thumbs)
  50. 13/06/2014 Eva fixed with stocks, pegged and whipped (18 thumbs)
  51. 12/06/2014 Maid tied, vibed, strapon fucked and spanked (17 thumbs)
  52. 11/06/2014 Buxom blonde strapped to a cross and vibed (15 thumbs)
  53. 10/06/2014 Two busty beauties are manhandled to the max (17 thumbs)
  54. 09/06/2014 Isabella tied to the bed and machine fucked (14 thumbs)
  55. 08/06/2014 All natural chic being bound for pleasure (16 thumbs)
  56. 07/06/2014 Madison gets strapped into the kneeling bench (16 thumbs)
  57. 06/06/2014 Cute babe tape-gagged, roped and undressed (14 thumbs)
  58. 05/06/2014 Busty blonde roped, clamped and strapon fucked (18 thumbs)
  59. 04/06/2014 Madison in painful session of abuse and torment (16 thumbs)
  60. 03/06/2014 Indian babe roped, ball-gagged and waxed (18 thumbs)


Whipped Ass
Masochistic women/slaves get bound/spanked


BDSM Movies

  1. 26/07/2014 Tied with plastic ties, rubber bands and clingfilm (4 movies)
  2. 26/07/2014 Two blond beauties tied and trained together (3 movies)
  3. 26/07/2014 Cassie get first time tied and exposed in public (4 movies)
  4. 26/07/2014 Sexy brunette tied, ball-gagged and fucked (5 movies)
  5. 26/07/2014 Harmony gets roped and trained by sadistic couple (4 movies)
  6. 25/07/2014 Brunette roped and gagged with big ball-gag (4 movies)
  7. 25/07/2014 Bobbi gets roped, trained and ass fucked (6 movies)
  8. 24/07/2014 Roped, strapped, suspended upside down, fucked (6 movies)
  9. 24/07/2014 Kobe roped, ball-gagged and forced to cum (6 movies)
  10. 23/07/2014 Jayden roped to a red velvet couch and vibed (5 movies)
  11. 22/07/2014 Frankie cuffed, ball-gagged, vibed and spanked (3 movies)
  12. 21/07/2014 Sexy domestic servant ass fucked in bondage (4 movies)
  13. 20/07/2014 Charlotte chained, roped, ass hooked and fucked (3 movies)
  14. 19/07/2014 Princess donna roped and trained to suck and fuck (6 movies)
  15. 18/07/2014 Pretty latina gets first time tied, spanked and fucked (3 movies)
  16. 17/07/2014 Bound to the box, ball-gagged, pegged and waxed (4 movies)
  17. 16/07/2014 Pretty brunette handcuffed, trained and fucked (5 movies)
  18. 15/07/2014 Trinity tied, vibed, waxed and anally strapon fucked (3 movies)
  19. 14/07/2014 Bound and ball-gagged beauty gets used and fucked (5 movies)
  20. 13/07/2014 Bodybuilder Lynn McCrossin bound and made to cum (5 movies)
  21. 12/07/2014 European hottie gets tied and fucked in public (6 movies)
  22. 11/07/2014 Kissy is bound, gagged, suspended and fucked (3 movies)
  23. 10/07/2014 Maria bellucci in first time bdsm with anal sex (3 movies)
  24. 09/07/2014 Blonde and brunette in bondage sex and domination (6 movies)
  25. 08/07/2014 Cuffed, gasmasked, pegged and trained to suck (6 movies)
  26. 07/07/2014 Roped, suspended, fisted and wired to cum (3 movies)
  27. 06/07/2014 Bodybuilder Lynn McCrossin bound and made to cum (4 movies)
  28. 05/07/2014 Naked shaved busty slut tied up and punished (5 movies)
  29. 04/07/2014 Rachel tied, ball-gagged, fixed and fucked (3 movies)
  30. 03/07/2014 Bodybuilder Lynn McCrossin bound and made to cum (4 movies)
  31. 02/07/2014 Caged, tormented, then strapped and fucked (5 movies)
  32. 01/07/2014 Roped, suspended, ball-gagged and fucked (4 movies)
  33. 30/06/2014 Big breasted brunette strapped and tortured (6 movies)
  34. 29/06/2014 Harmony roped, ball-gagged, hooked and vibed (5 movies)
  35. 28/06/2014 Chayse is bound to squirt from forced pleasure (6 movies)
  36. 27/06/2014 Tan hottie bound, punished and forced to cum (3 movies)
  37. 26/06/2014 Two slave girls tied and trained to fuck at the ranch (3 movies)
  38. 25/06/2014 Kidnapped by magician, tied, gagged, fucked (3 movies)
  39. 24/06/2014 Audrey ball-gagged, roped, strapped and fucked (3 movies)
  40. 23/06/2014 Blonde screams through her white ball-gag (6 movies)
  41. 22/06/2014 Pretty brunette gets roped and used for sex (3 movies)
  42. 21/06/2014 Kissy is bound, gagged, suspended and fucked (5 movies)
  43. 20/06/2014 Rough master makes slave girl to blowjob (5 movies)
  44. 19/06/2014 Two slavegirls cuffed, trained and tortured (6 movies)
  45. 18/06/2014 Sasha in a tight straitjacket and leather straps (4 movies)
  46. 17/06/2014 Kidnapped by magician, tied, gagged, fucked (4 movies)
  47. 16/06/2014 Kylie roped, suspended upside down and fucked (4 movies)
  48. 15/06/2014 Princess donna roped and trained to suck and fuck (3 movies)
  49. 14/06/2014 Tied outdoors, shocked and forced to cum (3 movies)
  50. 13/06/2014 Tied, ball-gagged, pegged and forced to cum (3 movies)


Top Free Sites



Archive pages: [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18]